Friday, August 28, 2026

SCOUNDREL & SCAMP THEATRE presents I'm Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire

THE SCOUNDREL & SCAMP THEATRE  ·  SEASON TEN  ·  TUCSON PREMIERE

A HILARIOUSLY TWISTED LOVE LETTER TO Y2K FANDOM

I'm Gonna Marry You

Tobey Maguire

by Samantha Hurley  ·  Directed by Annika Maher

  Arizona Premiere  ·  Mainstage  ·  Ages 17+ 

September 24 – October 11, 2026  ·  The Scoundrel & Scamp Theatre  ·  738 N 5th Avenue, Tucson

 

About the Play

About the Play

It's 2004. Low-rise jeans reign supreme, AIM away messages are works of art, and 14-year-old Shelby Hinkley is obsessed with one thing and one thing only: Tobey Maguire.

With her dad out of the picture, her mom totally oblivious, and her classmates treating her like a social outcast, Shelby has poured her entire soul into running the most devout Tobey Maguire fan club the internet has ever seen. President, activities director, and sole true believer.

But liking Tobey Maguire is not enough. No, Shelby has a plan — an absolutely foolproof, completely rational, no-notes plan: kidnap him and then marry him in her basement.

What could possibly go wrong? Well… turns out, a lot.

A zany Y2K-fueled farce, I'm Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire is a wild, unhinged joyride through fangirl culture, adolescent obsession, and the utterly unbreakable belief that your celebrity crush would totally love you back — if only they knew you existed.

Runtime: Approximately 90 minutes, no intermission

It's 2004.

Tobey Maguire

FAN CLUB

North American /

Antarctic Branch

PRESIDENT:

Shelby Hinkley

Members: 299

Est. 2001

 

  Spider-Man 

  Seabiscuit 

  The Cider House Rules 

"Come on, do I look like that?

Face it, I'm just some random guy

in your basement."

— Tobey

 

Performance Schedule

Ten performances over three weekends on the Mainstage. Thursday–Saturday evenings at 7:30 PM, Sundays at 2:00 PM. Runtime approximately 90 minutes, no intermission.

Day

Date

Time

Notes

Thursday

September 24, 2026

7:30 PM

Opening Night

Friday

September 25, 2026

7:30 PM

Saturday

September 26, 2026

7:30 PM

Sunday

September 27, 2026

2:00 PM

Friday

October 2, 2026

7:30 PM

Saturday

October 3, 2026

7:30 PM

Sunday

October 4, 2026

2:00 PM

Friday

October 9, 2026

7:30 PM

Saturday

October 10, 2026

7:30 PM

Sunday

October 11, 2026

2:00 PM

Closing Night

 

Tickets & Venue

Tickets

Adults  ·  $42

Seniors / Teachers  ·  $38

Students / Theatre Artists  ·  $29

  Free for Scoundrel Society members 

Buy online: scoundrelandscamp.org/marry-you-tobey

Box Office: 520-448-3300

boxoffice@scoundrelandscamp.org

Late seating at House Manager discretion — not guaranteed. Arrive early!

Venue

The Scoundrel & Scamp Theatre

at The Historic Y

738 N. 5th Avenue #131

Tucson, AZ 85705

Entrance: Off the parking lot of The Historic Y. Parking lot entrance is accessed from 5th Avenue.

Show Info: scoundrelandscamp.org/marry-you-tobey

All Shows: scoundrelandscamp.org

 

About the Play, Playwright & Director

About the Playwright

About the Director

About The S&S

Samantha Hurley

New York-based, Maine-raised comedy writer. Hurley studied theatre at Ithaca College and has written original sketches performed at UCB, Characters Welcome, PIT, and Brooklyn Comedy Collective.

I'm Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire premiered Off-Broadway in 2023 at the cell theatre in New York, followed by a critically acclaimed, extended run at the Southwark Playhouse in London in 2024. This is the Arizona premiere.

"This is for the girlies who were writing One Direction fan fiction."

— Samantha Hurley

Annika Maher

Co-Artistic & Managing Director of The Scoundrel & Scamp Theatre. Maher joined the S&S in 2025 alongside Zac Austin, bringing a commitment to community-centered, immersive storytelling and new work development.

I'm Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire marks the first full mainstage production of the S&S's 2026-2027 Season 10.

The Scoundrel & Scamp Theatre

Founded in 2016, S&S is an award-winning Tucson professional theatre company dedicated to immersive, imaginative storytelling for audiences of all ages. Located at The Historic Y in the 4th Avenue Shopping District.

Season 10 also features: The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane (Feb–Mar 2027), A Doll's House Part 2 (Apr–May 2027), Stone Soup (May 2027), Séance (Oct 2026), WoBo Show, Radio Hour, and Red Herring Puppets.

Scoundrel Society members get free tickets to all mainstage shows.

 

The Scoundrel & Scamp Theatre is dedicated to creating immersive, imaginative experiences for audiences of all ages and sharing diverse stories about and by historically excluded voices.  ·  738 N. 5th Ave #131, Tucson AZ 85705  ·  520-448-3300

 

-------------------------------------

TucsonStage home: www.TucsonStage.com

Recent announcements: http://tucsonstage.blogspot.com/

 

 

No comments: